Highline Beta 3.0: Vertical Venture Studios

Highline Beta 3.0: Vertical Venture Studios

We started Highline Beta in 2016. As we approach 9 years, we’re reflecting on everything we’ve learned and what comes next. The original thesis was “simple”--work with big companies to validate new opportunities beyond their core and spin out new startups. Those new companies become investable opportunities for us, de-risked through the validation work we do and the ongoing relationship they have with the corporate partner. We successfully championed corporate-startup collaboration models (Colgate-Palmolive, AB InBev, Intuit), got Fortune 500 companies to co-create new ventures, and 2x cash-on-cash returns to our initial investors within 18 months.

 

In the early days, very few people were familiar with the venture studio concept. We’d often get asked,What is a venture studio? How does it work?” In hindsight, we were a bit early.

Highline Beta 2.0: Proving Out Our Differentiated Venture Studio & Investment Model

Highline Beta 2.0 kicked off late 2019 / 2020 when we closed our 1st institutional GP/LP fund with RBC and BDC Capital as anchor LPs. The next mission was to prove that we could build & fund a portfolio of 20+ startups that successfully went through our 0-1 model, and attracted top tier 3rd party follow-on capital (thanks, in part, to our institutional VC rigor).

We knew there’d be plenty of ups & downs, but if successful, we would earn the right to scale both our venture studio platform and our role as a Day 1 institutional VCs, by attracting significantly more capital from global investors.

The period from 2020 to 2023 was transformative for venture studios, largely shaped by two key events: COVID-19 and the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB). At the onset of the pandemic, many VCs and LPs became more risk-averse as they focused on triaging existing portfolio companies. In 2021 there was a massive influx of startup capital and traditional VC models due to low interest rates and stimulus-driven liquidity, but SVB's collapse marked a significant moment for venture studio models as the funding cycle time increased. The number of venture studios globally peaked at ~1,000, but has since contracted, because of challenges faced in building a sustainable business model through revenue-generation and raising capital.

Highline Beta doubled down on investing in our venture studio platform and continued to work alongside amazing founders & corporate collaborators, building high quality ventures with <20% ownership (on average), ensuring aligned interests with founders, corporate collaborators and co-investors (versus the industry’s average 30% to 50%+ equity stake).

Venture studio startups are supposed to have a higher success rate (50% survive after 5 years) than traditional startups (10-30% survive after 5 years). Highline Beta starts 2025 with a portfolio of 21 startups in which 81% raised $1M+ follow-on, 1 successful exit & zero failures.

There will be failures, but also outlier returns and our 2nd strong exit will be announced soon. We’ve proven that our venture studio model works and that we’re strong pre-seed capital allocators vetted & trusted by leading institutions.

Highline Beta 3.0: Scaling Vertical Venture Studio Investment Models

2024-2025+ kicked off a new evolution as AI has further transformed how startups are built and funded within venture studio models.

AI is fundamentally reshaping the venture capital industry. Many firms will be disrupted with a weakening value proposition to founders and LPs. How founders raise pre-seed capital, how much capital they need to get to product-market fit and what hands-on venture support they need is all changing in real time.  

We’ve invested heavily to improve our venture studio platform’s value proposition, venture capital operations and foster AI innovation internally. Most importantly, we’re building off a strong foundation & profitable platform to now scale via vertical venture studios.

Through all of this experimentation we’ve learned a lot. It’s what inspired Ben to write content about venture studios, including on how to recruit founders/CEOs, how to design a corporate venture studio, how to build the right venture studio team and more. It’s also what convinced us that the future of venture studios is vertical.

A vertical venture studio builds and funds startups in a specific niche. In our view, the niche should be focused. For example, “Insurance” is too high level, because there’s a wide variety of startups you could build in insurance that are barely related. We’ve done a lot in insurance, working with corporate partners such as American Family Insurance, Green Shield, Cincinnati Insurance, Munich RE and others. We’ve also built startups (Flora, Relay Platform acquired by At-Bay) and made investments (Walnut Insurance)--but all of these examples vary widely. Flora is a D2C fertility insurance company, whereas Relay Platform was a spinout from American Family focused on reinsurance workflows (and eventually pivoted into B2B enterprise quoting for cyber insurance). In both of these cases, Flora and Relay, the playbooks used to validate, go-to-market, build the product, secure partnerships, monetize, etc. were different. So a vertical studio needs to go narrower.

How do we know if we’ve picked the right verticals?

It’s difficult to say, but generally we believe that there are startup opportunities in every vertical. As we build vertical venture studios we’re thinking of a few criteria:

  • The target customer base / market should be the same for every startup. Using the insurance example, Flora targets consumers, Relay targets enterprise carriers. Pick one customer base, so you know them insanely well and build up the right design partners / beta testers.
  • The go-to-market strategies should be the same for every startup. There’ll be nuances, but once you’ve figured out how to sell to customer group A, it should be the same for every startup you build.
  • The business model should be the same for every startup. It might vary a bit, but again, once you know how customer group B budgets and buys things, those insights should be used for future startups you build.

Most importantly, a vertical venture studio needs a competitive advantage through access to assets that are not easy to acquire. Assets may include: domain expertise, customers, partners, co-investors, acquirers, data, etc. You can’t build a vertical venture studio without being “on the inside” of the vertical.

Highline Beta is focusing on vertical venture studios

When you look at our current portfolio there’s definitely concentration in a few areas including financial services, insurance and logistics/sustainability. But going forward, we’re all-in on vertical venture studios.

Each vertical venture studio will:

  • Meet the criteria defined above, focusing on a narrow niche, where we bring in the right partners (be it a corporate, family office or individuals) that have privileged access to resources/assets/capabilities/network.
  • Be a part of Highline Beta, a connected holding entity / investment vehicle that leverages the platform we’ve built over 9 years, including our talent, methodologies, brand and network.
  • Build & fund startups, remaining opportunistic to how this gets done; whether it’s through a corporate collaboration leading to a spin-out, our own ideation, or a founder approaching us with an idea.
  • Develop its own playbooks for go-to-market, customer acquisition, monetization, etc. while using the fundamental principles we believe in when it comes to validating new opportunities.

We’re currently working on a few vertical venture studios, and will announce our first one soon.

  • If you’re a corporate that’s looking to build your own venture studio, please reach out. We see immense potential co-building vertical studios with corporate partners (which harkens to our original thesis)
  • If you’re a family office that’s interested in venture building, particularly around your current assets and/or investments, reach out. We’re working with a few family offices today.
  • If you’re a domain expert in a particular vertical and see opportunities to build multiple startups, reach out. We’ll continue to launch a few vertical studios every year and need the right partners to do it with.

After 9 years, we’re even more bullish on the venture studio model and see the potential to specialize in order to constantly improve how we build startups and the outcomes that result.

Thanks for reaching out. Be sure to check us out on LinkedIn for all of our current news and announcements.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.